Myth Busting: Think Your Recruiter Is Two-timing You? You Might Be Right

Kingston Human Capital

New Title

In your organisation, if you often hear your hiring manager complain that they feel like their external recruiter just ‘whipped a few resumes off a database', we would hazard a guess that you are entering into a 'contingent recruitment' or 'multi listed' relationship with your recruiters of choice.

 

It's fair to say that contingent recruitment has been around for a while. Sadly, despite its vintage, 'contingent recruitment' provides less than ideal outcomes for both the customer and the recruiter.

 

This is why most high-quality recruitment firms have moved away from offering it as a service.


What does Contingent or Multi-listed Recruitment mean?

 

Its a scenario where you:

  •      brief multiple recruitment agencies on your requirement
  •      give them a crappy deadline
  •      and then race them against each other
  •      and only pay the one who provides you with the candidate you hire

Sounds good, right? Nope, it’s a stupid move. Here is why:

Let’s draw back the curtain and spotlight what really happens when you list your recruitment project on a contingent basis with multiple recruiters.

 

First, that contingent recruiter will open their database and pop up a quickly written advertisement for your recruitment project. They'll pull a few quickly chosen resumes off their database. 

 

They will work on your project, but it is not the only project that they are working on. More often than not, contingent recruiters are working on 5-15 recruitment projects at any one time.

 

If that is the case, how on earth can your urgent and important requirement get the lion's share of their time and attention?

Recruiters who take on contingent work are not in an exclusive relationship with you. This means they are also working on 5-15 contingent recruitment projects for other people.

So how do you get high performing recruiters to work 'exclusively' on your urgent recruitment project?

 

Recruitment (talent acquisition) is one of the top priorities for every CEO right now because getting the right talent on your team determines if your organisation will be a phenomenon or a flop. 

 

Recruitment and talent acquisition is a professional service. So, just like you wouldn’t brief three accountants to do your tax return and then give them a crappy deadline to do it by, you shouldn’t multi-list or list your role on a contingent basis with a recruiter – it doesn’t generate quality results.

 

Instead, ensure your recruitment project gets all of your recruiters attention and expertise by asking them for an 'exclusivity' arrangement 

 

When they are exclusively focusing on your recruitment project they will evaluate more candidates against your role and develop a much higher quality shortlist for you, and you’ll end up with a much higher quality new team member, reducing stress, increasing productivity.

Don’t hire wrong; it causes so much anguish and pain. It creates significant drag, decreases productivity and can even affect the retention of your other staff.

To be guaranteed a higher level of service and to access better talent, opt for exclusive or retained arrangements with your recruiters and avoid contingent and multi-listed recruitment arrangements at all costs. You deserve amazing service and amazing outcomes. 

< Older Post

 Newer Post >

Other blogs you might like

Appointing an Executive Director & Chief Procurement Officer for the Department of Education

By Gerard Kerr • September 25, 2026
About The Department of Education The Department of Education required an Executive Director and Chief Procurement Officer to provide strategic leadership across procurement and facilities functions within one of Queensland's largest and most complex public sector environments. The role sat within the Finance, Procurement and Facilities Branch and required an executive capable of leading large-scale procurement strategy, influencing stakeholders across a decentralised operating environment and delivering commercial outcomes aligned with government priorities.  Kingston Human Capital was engaged to deliver an end-to-end executive recruitment and selection campaign, including executive search, market mapping, assessment, panel facilitation, reference checking and selection reporting

Finding the Right Talent for a Rare and Highly Specialised Leadership Role

By Gerard Kerr • September 25, 2026
About The Department of Environment, Science and Innovation (DESI) The Department of Environment, Science and Innovation (DESI) sought to appoint an Executive Director responsible for leading significant environmental policy initiatives and investment programs. The role was central to advancing environmental stewardship, innovation and long-term sustainability outcomes across Queensland. This executive leadership position carried responsibility for strategic environmental programs, stakeholder engagement and the administration of major government investment initiatives.

Recruiting a Chief Human Resources Officer for the Department of Housing and Public Works

By Gerard Kerr • September 14, 2026
About The Department of Housing and Public Works The Department of Housing and Public Works required a Chief Human Resources Officer capable of operating across a large and complex Queensland Government environment. The role sat within the Department's People and Culture function and required an executive capable of delivering strategic workforce leadership while influencing outcomes across a substantial public sector portfolio. The position extended beyond traditional HR leadership. The successful candidate needed expertise across workforce strategy, organisational transformation, industrial relations, governance, executive influence, workplace health and safety, and public sector accountability.